| 1 | Columbus Crew | MLS | Columbus, OH | 1890 |
| 2 | FC Cincinnati | MLS | Cincinnati, OH | 1881 |
| 3 | Columbus Crew 2 | MLS Next Pro | Columbus, OH | 1586 |
| 4 | Ambassadors FC Ohio | NPSL | Canton, OH | 1583 |
| 5 | University of Akron Zips | NCAA Division I | Akron, OH | 1568 |
| 6 | Ohio State University Buckeyes | NCAA Division I | Columbus, OH | 1537 |
| 7 | Xavier University Musketeers | NCAA Division I | Cincinnati, OH | 1521 |
| 8 | Akron City FC | USL League Two | Akron, OH | 1502 |
| 9 | University of Dayton Flyers | NCAA Division I | Dayton, OH | 1495 |
| 10 | Bowling Green State University Falcons | NCAA Division I | Bowling Green, OH | 1472 |
| 11 | Cleveland State University Vikings | NCAA Division I | Cleveland, OH | 1465 |
| 12 | Wright State University Raiders | NCAA Division I | Dayton, OH | 1430 |
| 13 | Kings Hammer FC Columbus | USL League Two | Columbus, OH | 1420 |
| 14 | FC Cincinnati 2 | MLS Next Pro | Cincinnati, OH | 1413 |
| 15 | University of Findlay Oilers | NCAA Division II | Findlay, OH | 1408 |
| 16 | University of Rio Grande RedStorm | NAIA | Rio Grande, OH | 1408 |
| 17 | Lake Erie College Storm | NCAA Division II | Painesville, OH | 1397 |
| 18 | Tiffin University Dragons | NCAA Division II | Tiffin, OH | 1396 |
| 19 | Case Western Reserve University Spartans | NCAA Division III | Cleveland, OH | 1393 |
| 20 | Cleveland SC | NPSL | Cleveland, OH | 1388 |
| 21 | Cedarville University Yellow Jackets | NCAA Division II | Cedarville, OH | 1387 |
| 22 | Kettering FC | UPSL | Dayton, OH | 1384 |
| 23 | Denison University Big Red | NCAA Division III | Granville, OH | 1383 |
| 24 | Manu Ledesma Academy | UPSL | Cincinnati, OH | 1382 |
| 25 | Lorain County Leviathan FC | USL League Two | Avon, OH | 1380 |
| 26 | Kenyon College Owls | NCAA Division III | Gambier, OH | 1380 |
| 27 | Mount Vernon Nazarene University Cougars | NAIA | Mount Vernon, OH | 1380 |
| 28 | Lions Football Club | UPSL | Columbus, OH | 1377 |
| 29 | Mercury Soccer | UPSL | Cincinnati, OH | 1377 |
| 30 | Fut Ohio SC | UPSL | Columbus, OH | 1371 |
| 31 | Leal United FC | UPSL | Reynoldsburg, OH | 1367 |
| 32 | Ashland University Eagles | NCAA Division II | Vermillion, OH | 1367 |
| 33 | Ohio Northern University Polar Bears | NCAA Division III | Ada, OH | 1366 |
| 34 | Otterbein University Cardinals | NCAA Division III | Westerville, OH | 1364 |
| 35 | University of Northwestern Ohio Racers | NAIA | Lima, OH | 1364 |
| 36 | Columbus Astray | UPSL | Columbus, OH | 1357 |
| 37 | University of Mount Union Purple Raiders | NCAA Division III | Alliance, OH | 1352 |
| 38 | Columbus Astray II | UPSL | Columbus, OH | 1351 |
| 39 | John Carroll University Blue Streaks | NCAA Division III | University Heights, OH | 1347 |
| 40 | Walsh University Cavaliers | NCAA Division II | North Canton, OH | 1346 |
| 41 | College of Wooster Fighting Scots | NCAA Division III | Wooster, OH | 1345 |
| 42 | Baldwin Wallace University Yellow Jackets | NCAA Division III | Berea, OH | 1342 |
| 43 | Wilmington College Quakers | NCAA Division III | Wilmington, OH | 1337 |
| 44 | Dayton Dutch Lions | USL League Two | West Carrollton, OH | 1336 |
| 45 | Wittenberg University Tigers | NCAA Division III | Springfield, OH | 1336 |
| 46 | Ohio Eagles FC | UPSL | Columbus, OH | 1335 |
| 47 | Ohio Wesleyan University Battling Bishops | NCAA Division III | Delaware, OH | 1335 |
| 48 | Capital University Comets | NCAA Division III | Bexley, OH | 1334 |
| 49 | Columbus Rough Riders FC | UPSL | Columbus, OH | 1330 |
| 50 | Manu Ledesma Academy II | UPSL | Cincinnati, OH | 1325 |
| 51 | Ohio Dominican University Panthers | NCAA Division II | Columbus, OH | 1322 |
| 52 | Franciscan University of Steubenville Barons | NCAA Division III | Steubenville, OH | 1322 |
| 53 | Ohio Elite FC | UPSL | Columbus, OH | 1319 |
| 54 | Ohio International FC II | UPSL | Columbus, OH | 1318 |
| 55 | Marietta College Pioneers | NCAA Division III | Marietta, OH | 1318 |
| 56 | Malone University Pioneers | NCAA Division II | Canton, OH | 1317 |
| 57 | Lightning SC | UPSL | Canton, OH | 1316 |
| 58 | Mahoning Trumbull United SC | UPSL | Youngstown, OH | 1316 |
| 59 | Hiram College Terriers | NCAA Division III | Hiram, OH | 1316 |
| 60 | Ohio International FC | UPSL | Columbus, OH | 1314 |
| 61 | Muskingum University Fighting Muskies | NCAA Division III | New Concord, OH | 1312 |
| 62 | Oberlin College Yeomen and Yeowomen | NCAA Division III | Oberlin, OH | 1303 |
| 63 | Miami SA Reserve | UPSL | Miami, OH | 1297 |
| 64 | Mount St. Joseph University Lions | NCAA Division III | Cincinnati, OH | 1286 |
| 65 | Bluffton University Beavers | NCAA Division III | Bluffton, OH | 1279 |
| 66 | Defiance College Yellow Jackets and Lady Jackets | NAIA | Defiance, OH | 1278 |
| 67 | Heidelberg University Student Princes | NCAA Division III | Tiffin, OH | 1266 |
| 68 | Toledo Villa FC | Midwest Premier League | Toledo, OH | 1228 |
| 69 | Cleveland Force SC | USL League Two | Cleveland, OH | 1224 |
| 70 | Toledo Villa FC | USL League Two | Toledo, OH | 1200 |