Indiana has 58 rated soccer clubs on Ranked XI across 14 leagues. The top men’s side is Indy Eleven (1698, USL Championship); the top women’s side is University of Notre Dame du Lac Fighting Irish (1727, NCAA Division I Women's). Every club here is rated on the same national scale as MLS and the grassroots, so a Indiana amateur side and a top-flight club are directly comparable. Updated 23 September 2026.
Indiana’s largest represented league is NAIA with 15 rated clubs. 43 men’s and 15 women’s sides carry a rating here, and the state’s best national position is #24. Clubs from Indiana whose divisions publish no usable table are listed on the map without a rating rather than being given an invented one.
58 rated clubs across 14 leagues — 43 men’s and 15 women’s. Unrated clubs are held and mapped but carry no number.
Which is the best soccer club in Indiana?
University of Notre Dame du Lac Fighting Irish at 1727, playing in NCAA Division I Women's. "Best" here means highest rating on the Ranked XI national scale, not league position.
Are amateur and pro clubs really on the same scale?
Yes. Cross-league placement is calibrated on about 600 U.S. Open Cup results, the one competition where clubs from different tiers meet, so a strong amateur side can rate above a weak professional one.
Every Ranked XI rating labels its basis. Cross-league placement is calibrated on ~600 U.S. Open Cup results — how the ratings work. Ranked XI is an independent project: not an official USSF or league ranking, not affiliated with any league or club, and not betting advice. Marks belong to their owners. About · FAQ · The US soccer pyramid · Corrections & removal.